Pasteurized Maternal Colostrum VS Dried Colostrum

Using Pasteurized Colostrum with the Perfect Udder® Feeding System vs Dried Colostrum

When properly handled, there is simply no substitute for high-quality, pasteurized maternal colostrum typically available on your own farm. Feeding the recommended volume provides each calf with 300–420g of Ig along with all the other beneficial components that mother nature intended it to have.

High-Quality Dried Colostrum in a Pouch High-Quality Dried Colostrum in a Pouch *Replacement dose = 3 bags
Pasteurized Colostrum — Perfect Udder® Feeding System Pasteurized Colostrum — Perfect Udder® Feeding System *Feeding 15% body weight Recommended
IgG delivered
High-Quality Dried Colostrum in a Pouch180g (60g Ig/bag)
Pasteurized Colostrum — Perfect Udder® Feeding System300–420g (50–70g Ig/L)
Source
High-Quality Dried Colostrum in a PouchDried whole bovine colostrum
Pasteurized Colostrum — Perfect Udder® Feeding SystemPasteurized maternal colostrum
Colostrum cost
High-Quality Dried Colostrum in a Pouch$80.97 (3× bags of 60g)
Pasteurized Colostrum — Perfect Udder® Feeding System$0.00 — it’s your colostrum!
Other costs
High-Quality Dried Colostrum in a PouchUnknown
Pasteurized Colostrum — Perfect Udder® Feeding System$14.00 — Matilda on a 500-cow farm ≈ $8.00; 2 Perfect Udder® Bags + 1 FeedTube ≈ $6.00
Cost per gram of IgG
High-Quality Dried Colostrum in a Pouch$0.45
Pasteurized Colostrum — Perfect Udder® Feeding System$0.03 – $0.05
Total cost / calf
High-Quality Dried Colostrum in a Pouch$94.97
Pasteurized Colostrum — Perfect Udder® Feeding System$14.00

*Prices based on retail online sources. Matilda pricing based on our subscription service. For more information, please contact our sales department.

New Standards of Immune Transfer

For thirty years, measuring IgG levels in calves has been crucial for assessing passive immunity, with levels above 10 g/L considered successful. Studies show a decrease in passive-immunity failure from 41% in 1991 to 13.7% in 2014, but morbidity rates remain high. Experts proposed new standards, emphasizing four categories based on IgG concentrations and recommending feeding 300g of IgG within 2 hours of birth or 400g within 24 hours.

CategoryIgG mg/mlSerum Total ProteinsBrix %
Excellent >25 >6.2 >9.4
Good 18.0–24.9 5.8–6.1 8.9–9.3
Fair 10.0–17.9 5.11–5.7 8.1–8.8
Poor <10 <5.1 <8.1

(Lombard et al., 2020)

Let’s Do Some Math…

2L of High-Quality Dried Colostrum

2L of High-Quality Dried Colostrum

  • 2L = 180g IgGs
  • 180 × 30% = 66g/L
  • 63 / 3.6 blood =

17.5 g/L IgGs = FAIR

6L of Pasteurized Colostrum in Perfect Udder® Bags

6L of Pasteurized Colostrum in Perfect Udder® Bags

  • 6L = 300g IgGs (assuming 50g IgG/L)
  • 300 × 35% = 105g/L
  • 105 / 3.6 blood =

29.5 g/L IgGs = EXCELLENT!!

Excellent passive transfer = 300+ IgG’s into the calf within the first 12 hours of life.

Issues with Dried Colostrum

  • It is consistently lower in Ig than fresh colostrum … in most cases, by a factor of 50% lower.
  • It is consistently lower in the myriad of vitamins, minerals and other biologically important proteins.
  • It will consistently fail to match the antibody profile of your herd of cows … because it is from another herd.
  • It is consistently easier to train an employee … but consistently worse for the calf. Which is more important?
  • It is consistently fed through containers, tubes and nipples that are not as biosecure as Perfect Udder®.
  • It is consistently more expensive than fresh colostrum when we look at $/gram of Ig.
Issues with Dried Colostrum

Look, if you do not have access to your own high-quality colostrum you should absolutely use a high-quality dried colostrum. However, with proper herd management, poor maternal colostrum should not be an issue. When combined with our Perfect Udder® Colostrum Management System, your calves will flourish and so will your production.

We’re Here to Help

Reach out to one of our Calf Consultants and they will get you taken care of.

  • Will Coombs
    Will Coombs Northeast Territory Manager
  • Jared Vander Schaaf
    Jared Vander Schaaf Northwest Territory Manager
  • Michaela McCracken
    Michaela McCracken Midwest Territory Manager
  • Michaela Schumacher
    Michaela Schumacher Southwest Territory Manager
  • Jorge Botero, MV
    Jorge Botero, MV Latin America Technical Specialist
  • Taylor Nichols
    Taylor Nichols Global Business Development
Get started

Ready when you are.

Have a question? Want a tour? Give us a call or drop a note — a Calf Consultant will get right back to you.